00:00 [music]
00:03 Welcome back to another episode of Unmuted. Today I'm joined by Sylvia
00:07 Kashish from Open Signal to dig into one of the biggest disconnects in mobile
00:11 right now, the gap between what consumers think 5G delivers and what
00:15 they actually experience dayto-day. We'll talk about why a 5G icon doesn't
00:20 always mean next generation performance, what the continued reliance on
00:23 non-standalone infrastructure means for users, and why many operators still
00:27 haven't made the leap to full 5G standalone even as the industry starts
00:32 hyping up 5G advanced and 6G. So, hi Sylvia, thanks so much for joining me.
00:38 >> Thanks Katherine, great to be here. >> So, let's start with this 5G icon on
00:43 consumer's phone. when they see this icon, they assume nextG performance,
00:48 right? But that's not often the reality. At least that's your experience in
00:52 London. From open signals data, how big is the gap between this perceived 5G
00:57 availability and actual 5G experience? >> It's actually a great question and
01:02 something that I bore all my friends that not telco experts with because when
01:06 you see the 5G icon on your phone, it actually doesn't mean you have 5G
01:10 service. That means you're within the reach of 5G network that can be really
01:15 far away. So I had this challenge on my own with my providers. I could see a 5G
01:20 icon on my phone. So I'd assume yes, I should have amazing comments. I should
01:24 have download upload latency, low latency, and have actual coverage at at
01:30 all times. But when I dug into it and I have the privilege of being the telco
01:34 industry and knowing what I'm what I'm talking to my provider, I actually found
01:37 out that I am not served by 5G at all. There's no 5G anywhere near me. I'm
01:43 actually served by 4G M that has a very limited spectrum bandwidth only 20 MHz
01:49 which means in 18 MHz spectrum band which for those that would know telco is
01:53 a not the best for providing very good speed. It's more of a kind of mid
01:58 coverage band. So what it means I'm not going to get the 5G experience at all.
02:02 So when you see 5G icon means somewhere far far away there might be 5G 5G mask
02:08 but you doesn't mean it translate into 5G like experience. So at open signal
02:13 it's so important to us to measure actual user experience. So we have
02:17 different type of metrics that we try to explain what is that end users get. So
02:22 5G availability and we introduced this recently is showing users whenever
02:28 they're within 5G signal coverage. It doesn't matter whether they're connected
02:33 or not connected. It means that there's somewhere that there's 5G coverage time
02:37 on 5G. That's the metric that we use to actually say what proportion of time
02:42 users are actively using 5G because quite often during the sessions that's
02:46 how operators set up the networks. When you do something that's not that
02:50 intensive in terms of I don't know you're just browsing, you don't need 5G,
02:53 right? So the 5G is not going to be uh switched on. Um so that's an important
02:58 distinction. And then when you bring in 5G standalone and I think that was part
03:02 of your question into that is even more complicated because 5G standalone
03:07 obviously requires doesn't rely on 4G core. So that's why 5G can go down on 4G
03:15 because of the non-standalone nature of it. With 5G stand what we see is that
03:19 only at least in the UK 90% of populated locations have 5G standalone. Then 68
03:26 61% of locations again populated that doesn't mean as population coverage
03:31 that's the metric that operators use we're saying those locations that people
03:34 actually live in work and so on that's 61% of being covered by at least one
03:39 operator in the UK and the rest is 4G and then only 1% what we see is actually
03:44 on 2G and 3G and why is important because we have a lots of network
03:48 sensiting happening so if you don't have a phone that have voice over LT enabled
03:56 and you within this 1% of coverage, you won't be able to make a phone call. You
04:00 won't be able to do that. And that's so important and we see lots of gaps in the
04:04 perceived experience and so on. And then when you actually think about like for
04:09 instance commuting or moving between in between that quite often going in and
04:14 out from locations that's when you will drop out of the coverage because the
04:17 handover is quite tricky. So it's really fascinating topic and and again I think
04:23 we should be very very clear that you see the icon it doesn't mean you
04:27 technically are connect to the next generation experience you can be still
04:30 on 4G network. >> Yeah and as this is happening and still
04:35 happening carriers are already talking about 5G advanced and even 6G right but
04:40 many still haven't fully deployed 5G standalone. So from your perspective
04:44 what's really holding them back? Is it mainly ROI or is it something deeper
04:50 going on? >> So return on investment is one of the
04:53 trickiest one. When you think about where are we at right now, we more than
04:58 halfway across 5G deployment cycle. So when you think about generation, it
05:03 typically is 10 years, right? So we're more than halfway halfway through. Still
05:07 majority of deployments are using NSA. So so they're not the so-called true 5G.
05:14 So when 5G was being designed, it was designed in this little triangle when
05:20 one was enhanced mobile broadband, one was a critical IoT and the other one was
05:24 massive IoT. So there's three different things that we're trying to achieve
05:28 achieve in there. So we achieved the superior bandwidth. So you can see
05:32 really high speeds, but the latency angle it is we're still getting there
05:38 and that's that's that's important. industry cases, enterprise use case and
05:42 we're seeing some of that is still we're getting there but we're not fully there
05:46 and in terms of the massive IoT that's again deploying IoT at scale still we're
05:52 not fully there in theory we should be getting we seeing some signals as well
05:56 but what is really important is uh 5G brings also more energy efficiency and
06:02 that's really key as as we know it's importance and our data actually shows
06:07 that users do experience lower latency. So 20 to 30% lower latency on standalone
06:14 versus non- standalone and that means that the gaming experience is better
06:18 consistency is better and so on. So it is important in terms of experience but
06:23 what we have seen actually it's a bit of a poster child experience is fixed wise
06:28 access. So even though it was not designed from the beginning fix the main
06:32 use case for 5G we've seen that carriers are very much being successful
06:38 especially in the US in India as well and some of the markets there's still
06:42 latent demand for connectivity fixet came in and is a posted chart for 5G so
06:48 it can actually use operators can actually monetize 5G like that and there
06:54 are still early signals you know we've seen operators doing network slicing
06:58 thing for instance in Singapore when there is F1 race can purchase a slice
07:04 that gives you access to network making sure that you are able to connect when
07:08 you're congested area and so on. So there are some use cases but I think the
07:13 question is why we where we are it is costly and operates are moving slowly
07:18 because of capex because of our return investment. Yeah, absolutely. And beyond
07:23 kind of measuring the gaming experience and things like that, which I know Open
07:27 Signal does, you also look at metrics like time on 5G and within 5G coverage,
07:32 things you sort of mentioned in your first answer. How do these measurements
07:37 help cut through some of the marketing claims about 5G and show what users are
07:43 actually experiencing? >> Yeah. So, so time on 5G when you
07:48 actually look at I don't have the figures in front of me but quite often
07:53 marketing claim would be we have the best 5G coverage. So coverage quite
07:58 often is of populated areas and it's just blank coverage but that doesn't
08:03 equal what proportion of time users actually spending on 5G. And really
08:07 interesting thing that we have done recently, we have something called the
08:11 global network excellence index. When we put together a number of metrics to
08:15 trying to assess network excellence, how good the networks are. So we look at
08:19 time that users spend on 4G and 5G. So they have access to modern
08:23 infrastructure. We look at consistent quality. So that's whether or not users
08:28 they had the experience good enough to be able to do everyday activities. So be
08:32 able to do video calls and so on. And third is download speed. And the reason
08:38 why it's important is because quite often you forget that it's not all about
08:43 speed, right? So when you're on 5G, you might not be experiencing 5G speed, but
08:47 you're not that bothered about the speed. You mostly bothered about the
08:50 fact that you cannot do what you want to do. So earlier today, I was doing a
08:54 video call. I'm on a very good network and I couldn't do anything. So that's
08:59 where the frustrations are. So time on 5G is when you are on 5G, but whenever
09:05 you're on the 5G is really whether or not the quality of your network is good
09:09 enough to be able to hold those calls and hold those videos and so on. But why
09:14 mentioning the network network excellence is we also added filters to
09:19 see what the performance and whether user experience differs when they're
09:22 high-end phones versus on low-end phones and there's a big gap. So for instance
09:27 you will see that higherend phones so so you know flagship on phones and so on
09:31 you have a better download experience better constant quality which also makes
09:36 you realize that the legacy legacy devices kind of the older devices might
09:42 not only be holding up the potential that networks provide but also showing
09:46 you that if you don't have access to modern not only modern infrastructure
09:50 but also modern devices your experience not might not be good enough. So kind of
09:54 like what we're trying to bring to the industry, a bit of an explanation why
09:58 certain things matter. So not only whether you're connected to 5G really
10:01 matters, it also matters what sort of device you have when you connect as
10:05 well. >> Yeah, there's a lot of factors at play
10:07 and actually let's talk more about legacy devices in markets like the UK.
10:11 You've warned that shutting down 2G and 3G could leave some users unconnected,
10:16 especially those relying on legacy devices. Where do you see the biggest
10:21 risks right now? or maybe just talk more about what your concerns are around
10:25 that. >> Sure. It's a very very timely question.
10:28 I mean like in the US you already had the networks being shut down and there
10:31 was quite a bit of effort in doing so and quite often this is not a very clean
10:36 technology update and upgrade in reality. So quite often what we see is
10:42 in certain cases like for instance in Taiwan when then Sans was happening
10:46 almost 100,000 people were still using 2G devices just 6 months before the
10:51 notice so that's really tricky because when the 2G spectrum no longer is going
10:56 to be available what's going to happen with those customers right and another
10:59 thing that's important is planning is super key so for instance we see the
11:04 opposite polar opposite of that is for instance in Sweden there was a lot of
11:09 national campaigns, awareness campaigns, making sure people are prepared for it.
11:14 So going to those vulnerable people quite often those that have legacy
11:19 legacy devices on legacy technology, they are the vulnerable people, those
11:23 that don't see a value of having a smartphone like somebody like a granny
11:27 that just wants to make a phone call, is not that bothered about sending pictures
11:31 of cards and so on. She just wants to be able to call in and out. But in the UK
11:36 we're also having the very same problem. And what is happening is when during the
11:42 3G sunset GMO2 has withdrew support with the inbound roaming for 2G some really
11:49 interesting use cases came up. So for instance particularly vulnerable people
11:54 but also uh those that rely like loan workers quite often they connected to
12:01 legacy technologies. they are in remote locations without 4G 5G coverage and so
12:08 how do you ensure that they don't get locked out without the service that's
12:12 number one number two is really really important at least in Europe eco so
12:17 that's the nationwide across the Europe uh scheme that all of the new cars
12:24 should have access to emergency calls you have it in the US you have all over
12:28 those boxes rely on 2G and 3G and we don't have a path forward So there's
12:33 going to be time when there's going to be an accident and you won't be able to
12:37 communicate with with services. So there are some real really true challenges as
12:42 well with that. And last but not least IoT devices. So quite often those IoT
12:47 devices we're relying on legacy networks and often times people don't know where
12:51 they are and you don't know where they connected. This could be a really
12:54 important uh telemetry service that measuring whether somebody's you know
12:59 taking the medicine and so on. So it's quite tricky and we often get caught by
13:05 the latest technology 5G as you mentioned but we forget that the old
13:10 legacy technologies serve the purpose for a very very long time. So we have to
13:14 figure out how we're going to move people away from them and ensure they're
13:18 still connected. >> Great.
13:19 >> And sorry I just last thing I just thought about it and it's just uh that's
13:22 how it happens. We hear a lot about direct to devices satellite services. So
13:26 not the staring type services when you have the broad bandwidth about those
13:31 services that supposed to be doing like emergency calls and so on. There's lots
13:36 of hype. There's lots of conversation about that and operators are definitely
13:40 having lots of partnerships. But at the moment we can only do emergency calls,
13:45 bit of texting and so on. So they're not going to be able to immediately replace
13:49 those people that get unconnected when legacy networks are going to be be
13:54 sunset. I'm glad you added that because it was actually my last question was
13:57 about direct to device satellite. But we are basically at time so I'm glad you
14:02 sort of slipped that in there. I appreciate it. Thank you so much for
14:05 taking the time to talk to me about this. It it sounds like there's still a
14:08 lot to figure out when it comes to really delivering on 5G. So, thank you
14:13 for sort of providing insight into that. >> Thank you. And I think I'm so passionate
14:17 about the topic and often times when we talk about 5G, 5G advanced, 6G, we
14:22 forget about the day-to-day reality of lift experience, what people experience.
14:27 So 5G advanced is out there, but it's still really hard to measure what
14:32 benefits and what value add services are there. There will be with AI like AI
14:37 coming in and so on. And it's going to be mostly the most of the impact will
14:40 happen on the network side. making the networks more efficient and in due time
14:45 consumers will see the benefits not just yet.
14:48 >> Yeah. All right. Perfect. Thank you so much.
14:50 >> Thank you.
No matching passages. Try another word.